Current:Home > reviewsEchoSense:Federal terrorism watchlist is illegal, unfairly targets Muslims, lawsuit says -Wealth Momentum Network
EchoSense:Federal terrorism watchlist is illegal, unfairly targets Muslims, lawsuit says
PredictIQ Quantitative Think Tank Center View
Date:2025-04-08 21:35:15
The EchoSenseCouncil on American-Islamic Relations is suing the U.S. government over its terrorism watchlist, claiming it disproportionately and unfairly targets Muslim Americans.
The suit, filed in U.S. District Court in Massachusetts on behalf of 12 Muslim American plaintiffs around the country, seeks not only to remove their names from the Federal Terrorist Screening Dataset but asks the court to declare it unconstitutional.
“Twenty years later, there is not a shred of credible evidence that the unconstitutional watch-listing of American Muslims has made America even the slightest bit safer,” said Amy Doukoure, staff attorney for the council’s Michigan chapter, which filed the suit along with CAIR’s national office and multiple other chapters.
The suit names 29 federal agencies as defendants and describes the plaintiffs as law-abiding Muslim American citizens, lawful permanent residents and asylees.
“They work hard, pay their taxes, pursue their education, and care for their families,” the suit reads. “They have never been indicted, charged, or convicted of any terrorism-related offense. And yet, without any notice or explanation, the federal government extrajudicially sentenced them to lifetime second-class citizenship.”
Federal terrorism watchlist includes 1.25 million names
The suit joins similar lawsuits winding their way through U.S. courts. In 2019, a U.S. District Court judge ruled that the watchlist violated the rights of Muslims, failing to inform them of their inclusion and leaving them unable to do anything about it, but the decision was overturned by Fourth Circuit Court judges.
The most recent suit filed comes three months after the council's national office issued a report, "Twenty Years Too Many," calling on President Joe Biden to suspend the watchlist.
Earlier this year, the council, known as CAIR, obtained what it said were leaked portions of a 2019 version of the watchlist, consisting of 1.25 million names.
“It came as no surprise that almost all of the names were identifiably Muslim and Middle Eastern in origin,” Lena Masri, CAIR’s national litigation director and general counsel, said at a recent news conference announcing the lawsuit.
A statistical analysis of the list commissioned by the group showed that more than 98% of the names – or 1.22 million of them – fit that description, she said.
“This cannot happen by accident,” Masri said, describing the watchlist as “a de facto Muslim registry.”
The lawsuit charges that the standards for being included on the watchlist are discriminatory and subjective, with criteria such as origin from and travel to Muslim-majority countries, attendance at mosque services and other Islamic events, donations to Muslim charities, frequency of prayer and the wearing of typical Muslim attire.
As a result, it says, the watchlist is ineffective, even as it is disseminated by the FBI and Terrorism Screening Center to other federal agencies, dozens of foreign countries and more than 18,000 state and local law enforcement agencies.
“Defendants… make it known that listed individuals should be treated as dangerous threats,” it charges. “…. The stigma and harm of watchlisting placement lasts a lifetime, even if Defendants eventually decide that an individual does not meet the vague, all-inclusive standard for placement and choose to remove an individual from the watchlist.”
New Jersey mayor was refused entry to White House event
As an example, Masri cited an instance earlier this year in which Mohamed Khairullah, the Syrian-born mayor of Prospect Park, New Jersey, was “uninvited” to an Eid al-Fitr celebration at the White House after the U.S. Secret Service denied him security clearance – allegedly because his name was included on an outdated version of the watchlist, from which he was allegedly later told he had been removed in or around 2022, according to the suit.
The Secret Service has declined to say why Khairullah, the longest-serving Muslim mayor in New Jersey, was denied clearance, and White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre deflected inquiries about the mayor’s watchlist status, saying the decision was a Secret Service matter.
Khairullah called the May incident “disappointing” and “shocking” but had suspected he was on the watchlist since 2019, when he began experiencing aggressive questioning and searches while traveling.
Similarly, Masri said, other American Muslims have been subjected to mass surveillance and interrogated about their religious beliefs and practices whenever they return on an international flight or cross the U.S. border.
“American Muslims on the list are publicly humiliated in front of their friends, family members and coworkers,” Masri said. “They are surveilled and harassed when they travel and their private data is downloaded from all of their electronic devices… They have lost their jobs; they have been denied security clearances; they have been denied licenses, gun permits and immigration benefits.”
Michigan man said he 'felt humiliated'
Nidal El-Takach, a Michigan man who is among the plaintiffs in the suit, said at the news conference that starting in 2017, he began to be repeatedly detained and questioned before and after international flights, including trips he made to Lebanon to visit his ailing mother.
He recalled the first instance, in July 2017, as he and his two children arrived in Detroit from Lebanon. When the plane arrived at the gate, he said, an officer’s voice sounded over the loudspeaker asking the passengers to remain seated.
El-Takach said the officer then named him and his two children and asked them to exit the aircraft.
“That alone sparked a lot of fear,” he said. “That was the moment when my life and my kids’ lives changed.”
He complied with the officers’ requests, he said; he gave them the password to his phone. He was asked whether he attended Friday prayers, and whether his wife wore a hijab.
“I felt humiliated,” he said. “My religious freedom was violated and I feared for my and my kids’ safety.”
Terrorism list can spark trauma for Muslim Americans
El-Takach said he was released after a few hours. But that would be just the first of many times that he, and sometimes his children, would be detained, interrogated and patted down without ever being told why. Once, he said, he was asked to wait while an explosives specialist was summoned to check his bag.
“I was traveling with my kids,” El-Takach said. “That was outrageous.”
El-Takach said the repeated trauma of such incidences ultimately gave him such severe anxiety that he sought medical help. In 2021, when his mother passed away, he said he was too upset by his experiences to attend her funeral.
Doukoure, of CAIR-Michigan, said El-Takach’s experience is just one example of what many Muslim Americans have gone through because of the watchlist.
“Muslims get put on the list without any notice, without being provided the reason for their inclusion and without any real process to get off that list,” she said. “And they’re forever tainted with the stigma of having been on the list in the first place.”
veryGood! (4)
Related
- Senate begins final push to expand Social Security benefits for millions of people
- How to watch the U.S. Open amid Disney's dispute with Spectrum
- AI used to alter imagery or sounds in political ads will require prominent disclosure on Google
- Federal judge deals another serious blow to proposed copper-nickel mine on edge Minnesota wilderness
- Working Well: When holidays present rude customers, taking breaks and the high road preserve peace
- Why No. 3 Alabama will need bullies or a magician for its showdown against No. 10 Texas
- Disney+ deal: Stream service $1.99 monthly for 3 months. Watch 'Ashoka,' 'Little Mermaid' and more
- Joe Jonas Performs Without His Wedding Ring After Confirming Sophie Turner Divorce
- New Mexico governor seeks funding to recycle fracking water, expand preschool, treat mental health
- 3 sailors rescued after sharks attack and partially destroy their inflatable boat off Australian coast
Ranking
- What to watch: O Jolie night
- Australia and China open their first high-level dialogue in 3 years in a sign of a slight thaw
- Long opposed to rate increases, Erdogan now backs plan that includes raising rates, minister says
- New federal rule may help boost competition for railroad shipments at companies with few options
- Angelina Jolie nearly fainted making Maria Callas movie: 'My body wasn’t strong enough'
- Bill Gates' foundation buys Anheuser-Busch stock worth $95 million after Bud Light financial fallout
- The Riskiest Looks in MTV VMAs History Will Make Your Jaw Drop
- Week 2 college football predictions: Here are our expert picks for every Top 25 game
Recommendation
Kylie Jenner Shows Off Sweet Notes From Nieces Dream Kardashian & Chicago West
Prince Harry Returns to London for WellChild Awards Ahead of Queen Elizabeth II's Death Anniversary
Louisiana gubernatorial candidates set to debate crime, economy and other issues 5 weeks from vote
4 Roman-era swords discovered after 1,900 years in Dead Sea cave: Almost in mint condition
What to know about Tuesday’s US House primaries to replace Matt Gaetz and Mike Waltz
Long opposed to rate increases, Erdogan now backs plan that includes raising rates, minister says
City lawsuit says SeaWorld San Diego theme park owes millions in back rent on leased waterfront land
Week 2 college football predictions: Here are our expert picks for every Top 25 game