Current:Home > InvestExperts doubt Trump will get conviction tossed in "hush money" case despite Supreme Court ruling -Wealth Momentum Network
Experts doubt Trump will get conviction tossed in "hush money" case despite Supreme Court ruling
View
Date:2025-04-16 07:35:48
Six years after the Manhattan District Attorney's Office began an investigation that resulted in Donald Trump becoming the first former president ever convicted of a crime, the case continues to be beset by extraordinary curveballs.
The latest is Monday's landmark Supreme Court decision on presidential immunity that led to Tuesday's decision by the judge in his New York criminal case to postpone Trump's sentencing.
"That wasn't just a curve, that was a 12-6 breaking ball," said Michael Cohen, Trump's ex-attorney who was a key witness in the case against him, referring to a baseball pitch that befuddles hitters when it sharply drops.
The Supreme Court found that former presidents enjoy broad immunity for official acts, and said evidence involving those acts cannot be used in prosecutions over unofficial activity. Soon after the decision was released on Monday, Trump's team sent a letter to New York Justice Juan Merchan asking for permission to file a motion laying out why the verdict in Trump's case should be thrown out.
Merchan granted the request and pushed back Trump's sentencing from July 11 to Sept. 18 to consider the question.
As the case enters a new phase, experts remain skeptical that Trump's 11th-hour effort to overturn his conviction will be successful.
"If he engaged in unlawful conduct before he became president, it doesn't seem to me that his efforts when he was president, to either cover up or address that conduct, will be immunized from criminal liability," said Pace University law professor Bennett Gershman, a former New York prosecutor.
Trump's lawyers indicated in their letter that their motion will focus on evidence introduced at trial that related to social media posts, public statements and witness testimony from his time in office. Much of that evidence pertained to what prosecutors described as a 2018 "pressure campaign" designed to keep Cohen from divulging incriminating information about Trump.
"Michael is a businessman for his own account/lawyer who I have always liked & respected. Most people will flip if the Government lets them out of trouble, even if it means lying or making up stories," Trump wrote in one April 2018 tweet entered into evidence.
Trump was convicted in May of 34 counts of falsification of business records for signing off on an effort to cover up reimbursements for a "hush money" payment to an adult film star as he ran for office in 2016.
CBS News legal analyst Rikki Klieman said the context and timing of that scheme make it unlikely Merchan will reverse the conviction.
"I do not believe that the verdict will be set aside," Klieman said. "What is this case about? It's about conduct before he was president of the United States that was designed to influence the outcome of the 2016 election."
Gary Galperin, a Cardozo Law School professor and former Manhattan prosecutor, said Merchan can conclude that some evidence should not have been shown at trial, and still decline to set aside the verdict.
"If there's enough evidence beyond the 'official acts' to sustain the conviction, then it would be what the courts call 'harmless error,'" Galperin said. "No trial is perfect. And the criminal justice system doesn't anticipate or expect perfection."
If Merchan concludes that enough evidence and testimony related to official acts was introduced during the trial to warrant setting aside the verdict, he would likely point to "the exact pieces of evidence" that violated the Supreme Court's opinion, Klieman said.
Prosecutors would be able to use Merchan's findings as guidance if they decided to seek another trial.
"In the event that it is set aside, I would expect that the government would move to re-try the case, and exclude the evidence Judge Merchan decides could be in violation of the Supreme Court decision," Klieman said.
Cohen said it occurred to him Tuesday night that he might be asked to testify against Trump again in a trial do-over.
As Trump's former lawyer and fixer, and now scorned vocal critic, Cohen faced four days of painstaking, bruising examination during the trial. Trump's lawyers painted him a serial liar determined to seek revenge against the former president, while building a new celebrity career off that effort.
Would he willingly go through that again?
"As it relates to the question of whether or not I'd testify again, I'll take it under advisement," Cohen said. "I'll let you know when the time comes."
Graham KatesGraham Kates is an investigative reporter covering criminal justice, privacy issues and information security for CBS News Digital. Contact Graham at KatesG@cbsnews.com or grahamkates@protonmail.com
veryGood! (46235)
Related
- EU countries double down on a halt to Syrian asylum claims but will not yet send people back
- WNBA Finals winners, losers: Series living up to hype, needs consistent officiating
- Trump tested the limits on using the military at home. If elected again, he plans to go further
- This week's full hunter's moon is also a supermoon!
- Bill Belichick's salary at North Carolina: School releases football coach's contract details
- Giants vs. Bengals live updates: Picks, TV info for Week 6 'Sunday Night Football' game
- Most AAPI adults think legal immigrants give the US a major economic boost: AP-NORC/AAPI Data poll
- Trial set to begin for suspect in the 2017 killings of 2 teen girls in Indiana
- The 401(k) millionaires club keeps growing. We'll tell you how to join.
- An Election for a Little-Known Agency Could Dictate the Future of Renewables in Arizona
Ranking
- Sam Taylor
- Sacha Baron Cohen talks disappearing into 'cruel' new role for TV show 'Disclaimer'
- Shark Tank's Mark Cuban, Lori Greiner and More Reveal Their Most Frugal Behavior
- Kansas tops AP Top 25 preseason men’s basketball poll ahead of Alabama, defending champion UConn
- Former Danish minister for Greenland discusses Trump's push to acquire island
- Man with loaded gun arrested at checkpoint near Donald Trump’s weekend rally in Southern California
- What is Columbus Day? What to know about the federal holiday
- Olympians Noah Lyles and Junelle Bromfield Are Engaged
Recommendation
Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Triathlon
The DNC wants to woo NFL fans in battleground states. Here's how they'll try.
Back to the hot seat? Jaguars undermine Doug Pederson's job security with 'a lot of quit'
Ruth Chepngetich smashes woman's world record at Chicago Marathon
Gen. Mark Milley's security detail and security clearance revoked, Pentagon says
What is Columbus Day? What to know about the federal holiday
Bachelor Nation’s Jason Tartick and Kat Stickler Break Up After Brief Romance
Not exactly smooth sailing at the 52nd Albuquerque balloon fiesta after 4 incidents