Current:Home > Invest10 Senators Call for Investigation into EPA Pushing Scientists Off Advisory Boards -Wealth Momentum Network
10 Senators Call for Investigation into EPA Pushing Scientists Off Advisory Boards
Poinbank View
Date:2025-04-11 01:46:06
A group of Senate Democrats is calling for an expanded investigation into efforts by the Trump Environmental Protection Agency to effectively push independent scientists off key EPA advisory boards and replace them with scientists from the fossil fuel and chemical industries.
In a letter sent to the Government Accountability Office on Thursday, the 10 senators asked the GAO to investigate a new directive, issued by EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt on Oct. 31, that restricts any scientist who has received EPA funding from serving on the agency’s scientific advisory panels.
Pruitt said the move was intended to clear up conflicts of interest and to rid advisory panel members of financial ties to the agency. But scientific groups, academics and advocacy organizations have all pointed out that it will mean the most experienced scientists—whose qualifications earn them government grants in the first place—will no longer be able to serve in these roles.
“The double-standard is striking: an academic scientist that receives an EPA grant for any purpose cannot provide independent advice on a completely different subject matter on any of EPA’s science advisory boards,” the senators wrote, “while industry scientists are presumed to have no inherent conflict even if their research is entirely funded by a company with a financial stake in an advisory board’s conclusions.”
Five days after Pruitt issued the directive, The Washington Post reported that he appointed 66 new members to advisory panels, many of them with ties to industries the agency regulates. Several panel members stepped down.
“Under this new policy, EPA will be replacing representatives of public and private universities including Harvard, Stanford, Ohio State University, and the University of Southern California with scientists who work for Phillips 66, Total, Southern Company, and the American Chemistry Council,” the senators wrote.
In response to a request for comment, an EPA spokesperson replied: “The Administrator has issued a directive which clearly states his policy with regard to grantees.” The agency did not respond to questions about whether new members will be required to sign conflict of interest declarations or undergo a review process.
Earlier this year, the EPA said it would not renew the terms of members of its broader Board of Scientific Counselors, and beyond EPA, the administration has allowed other scientific boards to expire altogether. In August, the acting head of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) told members of an advisory panel for the National Climate Assessment that it would allow the panel’s charter to lapse.
The recent Pruitt directive is similar to legislation long pushed by Republicans in Congress, including a bill introduced earlier this year called the EPA Science Advisory Board Reform Act.
Science organizations have pointed out that anyone receiving a federal grant undergoes a merit review, which scrutinizes their professional standards and ethics, and that grant applicants have to declare they have no conflicts of interest before receiving government grants.
“EPA’s decisions have real implications for the health and well-being of Americans and in some cases people worldwide,” wrote Chris McEntee, the executive director of the American Geophysical Union. “By curtailing the input of some of the most respected minds in science, Pruitt’s decision robs the agency, and by extension Americans, of a critically important resource.”
The senators’ letter on Thursday follows a previous request to the GAO, the investigative arm of Congress, to investigate the EPA’s policies and procedures related to advisory panels.
veryGood! (2)
Related
- A Mississippi company is sentenced for mislabeling cheap seafood as premium local fish
- Demi Lovato's Chic Hair Transformation Is Cool for the Summer
- Rihanna Reveals Why Her 2024 Met Gala Look Might Be Her Most Surprising Yet
- No one rocks like The Rolling Stones: Mick Jagger, band thrill on Hackney Diamonds Tour
- Most popular books of the week: See what topped USA TODAY's bestselling books list
- Travis Kelce Calls Taylor Swift His Significant Other at Patrick Mahomes' Charity Gala in Las Vegas
- Suns' championship expectations thwarted in first round as Timberwolves finish sweep
- The Demon of Unrest: Recounting the first shots of the Civil War
- Tom Holland's New Venture Revealed
- Post Malone reveals his love of country music, performs with Brad Paisley at Stagecoach
Ranking
- Macy's says employee who allegedly hid $150 million in expenses had no major 'impact'
- Demonstrators breach barriers, clash at UCLA as campus protests multiply: Updates
- NFL draft takeaways: Cowboys passing on RB opens door to Ezekiel Elliott reunion
- Pair of $1 bills with same printing error could be worth thousands. How to check
- Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
- Republicans seeking Georgia congressional seat debate limits on abortion and immigration
- AIGM puts AI into Crypto security
- The Best Mother-in-Law Gifts That Will Keep You on Her Good Side & Make Her Love You Even More
Recommendation
House passes bill to add 66 new federal judgeships, but prospects murky after Biden veto threat
Deepfake of principal’s voice is the latest case of AI being used for harm
West Virginia and North Carolina’s transgender care coverage policies discriminate, judges rule
Hong Kong transgender activist gets ID card reflecting gender change after yearslong legal battle
B.A. Parker is learning the banjo
This summer, John Krasinski makes one for the kids with the imaginary friend fantasy ‘IF’
Florida sheriff says deputies killed a gunman in shootout that wounded 2 officers
A Florida sheriff says 10 people were wounded by gunfire during an argument at a party venue